Can a Christian Have Bad Character?
Yes, a Christian can have bad character traits because becoming a Christian does not mean becoming instantly perfect. However, genuine Christian maturity should produce ongoing character growth, repentance, accountability, and an increasing desire to become more like Christ.
This distinction matters especially in Christian premarital counseling and Christian dating.
Every person you consider marrying will have flaws, regardless of gender, race, ethnicity, upbringing, or how long they have been a Christian.
The important question isn’t whether someone ever demonstrates selfishness, pride, defensiveness, anger, or dishonesty.
The better question is: What happens when those character problems are exposed?
Think of Christianity like a uniform. A uniform identifies who someone represents, but wearing it does not guarantee that they will represent that organization perfectly.
In the same way, identifying as a Christian is meaningful, but Christian character becomes visible in how a person responds to correction, temptation, conflict, failure, and responsibility.
The Character Method™ describes this as moving from self-protection toward self-awareness—learning to examine your own contribution before concentrating on your partner’s faults.
Christianity Does Not Mean Character Perfection
One mistake Christian singles can make is assuming that finding a Christian spouse means finding someone without serious character weaknesses.
Scripture doesn’t teach that.
In Colossians 3:5–14, Paul is speaking to believers, yet he instructs them to put away behaviors and attitudes such as anger, malice, slander, and lying while putting on compassion, kindness, humility, gentleness, patience, forgiveness, and love.
In context, Paul’s point is not that Christians have already achieved perfect character. Their new identity in Christ should increasingly affect the kind of people they become. Biblical scholarship similarly notes that Paul’s lists describe character traits Christians are called to reject and cultivate and that the passage does not assume believers have reached perfection.
That’s sanctification.
Christianity doesn’t mean perfection. It means Christ has given your character a new direction.
So a Christian may struggle with pride.
The important question is whether that person can eventually humble themselves.
A Christian may become defensive.
The question is whether they can receive correction and accept responsibility.
A Christian may hurt you. The question is whether conviction leads toward confession, repair, and changed behavior.
There is a significant difference between struggling with bad character and surrendering to bad character.
“Nobody’s Perfect” Should Never Become an Excuse
“Nobody’s perfect” is true.
But it can become dangerous when Christians use it to normalize persistent unhealthy behavior.
Imagine an athlete wearing a team uniform who repeatedly ignores the coach, refuses to practice, breaks team rules, blames teammates, and rejects correction.
Pointing to the jersey doesn’t resolve the contradiction between the team the athlete represents and the way the athlete behaves.
The same principle applies in Christian relationships.
Someone may attend church, know Scripture, pray with you, and openly identify as Christian. Those things matter.
But before marriage, you also need to pay attention to their patterns of character.
The Character Method™ identifies patterns such as selfishness, pride, defensiveness, secrecy, lying, revenge, and disrespect as barriers that can damage a relationship.
Grace explains why imperfect people can still be loved.
Grace does not make destructive patterns irrelevant.
What Does Relationship Research Tell Us?
Relationship research reinforces why patterns matter.
Research summarized by The Gottman Institute identifies criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling as particularly destructive relational patterns. Gottman’s longitudinal research found that patterns observed during couple interactions could be used to predict divorce with high accuracy across multiple studies.
Defensiveness is especially relevant to character development because it often shifts responsibility away from ourselves.
Gottman’s work describes defensiveness as a form of self-protection that can involve making excuses or reversing blame rather than accepting responsibility.
That aligns with an important principle of The Character Method™:
Communication problems are often character problems expressing themselves through communication.
A communication technique may help someone phrase an apology better. Character determines whether they’re willing to take responsibility in the first place.
This is why Christian premarital preparation needs to go deeper than teaching couples how to communicate. Couples also need to examine the character of the people doing the communicating.
What Should You Look for in a Christian Before Marriage?
Instead of asking only, “Is this person a Christian?”, add another question:
“How does this person represent Christ when their character is tested?”
Pay particular attention to what happens when they’re wrong.
Do they take ownership or immediately blame you?
Can they receive correction without punishing the person who corrected them?
Can they admit wrongdoing without minimizing it?
Do they apologize specifically?
Does repentance eventually produce behavioral change?
Can they tell the truth when honesty costs them something?
And perhaps most importantly, are they increasingly becoming more humble, compassionate, patient, forgiving, truthful, and loving?
These questions don’t create a perfection test.
They create a character-growth test.
Don’t Only Examine the Person You’re Dating
There is another side of Christian premarital counseling that is easy to overlook.
These questions shouldn’t only be asked about your boyfriend, girlfriend, fiancé, or fiancée.
Ask them about yourself.
The Character Method™ calls this Mirror Before Window: instead of immediately looking through the window at everything your partner needs to change, first look in the mirror and examine what you’re bringing into the relationship.
What happens when you’re corrected?
What happens when you don’t get your way?
What happens when your pride gets challenged?
What happens when apologizing costs you something?
Christian premarital counseling shouldn’t only help you determine whether you’ve found the right person.
It should help you become the kind of person capable of building a healthy Christian marriage.
Christian Character: Look for Direction, Not Perfection
A true Christian with good character is not someone who never sins.
It’s someone whose failures increasingly lead them back toward truth, humility, repentance, grace, and transformation through Christ.
That is very different from someone who uses Christianity as a uniform while consistently rejecting accountability, excusing destructive behavior, manipulating Scripture, hiding serious patterns, or showing little interest in becoming more Christlike.
Jesus warns in Matthew 7:15–20 that outward religious appearance can be deceptive. That doesn’t give Christians permission to label every immature believer a “wolf in sheep’s clothing.” It does mean that spiritual claims should not require us to ignore persistent contradictory patterns.
So don’t demand perfection from someone simply because they’re Christian.
But don’t ignore character simply because they’re Christian either.
The takeaway
The uniform tells you who someone claims to represent. Character shows you how they’re representing Him.
If you’re preparing for marriage, don’t just ask whether you’re spiritually compatible. Examine the character patterns you’re both bringing into the covenant—and whether those patterns are actually being transformed by Christ.
Looking to prepare for your Christian marital journey? Or are you newly married and looking to live a Gospel-centered marriage?
Follow: The Premarital Prep Guy (Facebook) Instagram: The Premarital Prep Guy
Poor communication is the #1 problem in relationships.
Follow us to learn to have the hard conversations before the hard times.
Looking for a Gospel-centered premarital program? (in-person or virtual options available)
Need a Christian Speaker that’s also a marriage counselor? Book me for(virtual options available): Book a Call
- Panel Discussions
- Seminars
- Marriage Conferences
- Workshops